Hukukça

All cases

Cases

25 cases

Different outcomes

Election law

Absolute nullity of CHP's 38th Congress and the leadership dispute

Was Ankara Regional Court of Appeal 36th Civil Chamber's absolute-nullity decision on the CHP 38th Congress lawful?

Unlawful94.2%
Lawful5.8%
369 Opinions
6 Questions
On appeal

Fair trial

İBB/İmamoğlu main criminal case: pre-trial detention, suspension from office, and fair trial

Was Ekrem İmamoğlu's pre-trial detention in the corruption investigation lawful?

Unlawful99.5%
Lawful0.5%
332 Opinions
6 Questions
Active

Administrative law

Ekrem İmamoğlu diploma cancellation and eligibility dispute

Was Istanbul University's cancellation of Ekrem İmamoğlu's diploma lawful?

Unlawful90.5%
Lawful9.5%
79 Opinions
4 Questions
On appeal

Fair trial

İmamoğlu-Yanardağ political espionage and TELE1 case

Was the continued pre-trial detention of İmamoğlu, Yanardağ, Özkan, and Gün in the political espionage case lawful?

Unlawful100.0%
Lawful0.0%
43 Opinions
2 Questions
Active

Criminal procedure

Esenyurt Ahmet Özer trustee process

Was the pre-trial detention order against Ahmet Özer lawful?

Unlawful99.2%
Lawful0.8%
179 Opinions
4 Questions
Partly final

Criminal procedure

Diamond Tema investigation under TCK Article 216 and arrest warrant

Was opening an investigation under TCK Article 216 and issuing an arrest warrant for Diamond Tema because of his remarks in the Yer6 discussion on sharia lawful?

Unlawful100.0%
Lawful0.0%
14 Opinions
1 Questions
Monitoring

Constitutional adjudication

Can Atalay Constitutional Court decisions and Court of Cassation/TBMM process

Was the non-implementation of the Constitutional Court's violation decisions for Can Atalay lawful?

Unlawful98.1%
Lawful1.9%
136 Opinions
1 Questions
Monitoring

Criminal procedure

Selahattin Demirtaş ECHR judgments and release process

Was it lawful not to release Selahattin Demirtaş despite the ECHR judgments?

Unlawful98.3%
Lawful1.7%
97 Opinions
1 Questions
Monitoring

Fair trial

Gezi Trial, Osman Kavala, and ECHR decisions

Were the convictions of Osman Kavala and other defendants in the Gezi Trial lawful?

Unlawful99.4%
Lawful0.6%
128 Opinions
2 Questions
Monitoring

Constitutional adjudication

Withdrawal from the Istanbul Convention and Council of State process

Was withdrawal from the Istanbul Convention by presidential decision lawful?

Unlawful99.4%
Lawful0.6%
152 Opinions
1 Questions
Final

Election law

YSK's 2019 Istanbul election annulment decision

Was YSK's annulment of the March 31, 2019 Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality mayoral election lawful?

Unlawful99.5%
Lawful0.5%
96 Opinions
1 Questions
Final

Constitutional adjudication

Erdoğan's third presidential candidacy in 2023

Was YSK's acceptance of Recep Tayyip Erdoğan's renewed candidacy in the 2023 presidential election, and its rejection of third-candidacy objections, lawful?

Unlawful85.0%
Lawful15.0%
73 Opinions
1 Questions
Final

Constitutional adjudication

Hagia Sophia and the Council of State's 2020 judgment

Was the Council of State 10th Chamber's 2020 annulment of the 1934 Council of Ministers decision designating Hagia Sophia as a museum lawful?

Unlawful70.3%
Lawful29.7%
40 Opinions
1 Questions
Final

Constitutional adjudication

2023 additional motor vehicle tax and Constitutional Court decision

Was the Constitutional Court's refusal to annul the 2023 additional motor vehicle tax regulation lawful?

Unlawful83.3%
Lawful16.7%
21 Opinions
1 Questions
Final

Fair trial

Temporary freeze on HDP Treasury aid and Constitutional Court interim order

Was the Constitutional Court's temporary freeze order on HDP's Treasury-aid account lawful?

Unlawful95.3%
Lawful4.7%
27 Opinions
1 Questions
Final

Constitutional adjudication

Removal of the Student Oath and Council of State process

Was the Council of State's finding that removing the Student Oath was lawful itself lawful?

Lawful59.4%
Unlawful40.6%
22 Opinions
1 Questions
Final

Fair trial

Multiple-bar-association regulation and Constitutional Court rejection

Was the Constitutional Court's refusal to annul the multiple-bar-association regulation lawful?

Unlawful98.1%
Lawful1.9%
98 Opinions
1 Questions
Final

Constitutional adjudication

Participation of headscarved lawyers in judicial proceedings

Was the Council of State decision enabling headscarved lawyers to participate in judicial activities lawful?

Lawful87.9%
Unlawful12.1%
46 Opinions
1 Questions
Final

Constitutional adjudication

Treating the State of Emergency Commission as an effective remedy

Was treating the State of Emergency Commission as an effective remedy lawful?

Unlawful87.0%
Lawful13.0%
17 Opinions
1 Questions
Final

Prohibition of discrimination

Public-service headscarf freedom and the 2013 dress regulation

Was removing the public-service headscarf ban through the 2013 dress-regulation amendment lawful?

Lawful94.7%
Unlawful5.3%
20 Opinions
1 Questions
Final

Constitutional amendment

2008 university headscarf constitutional amendment and Constitutional Court annulment

Was the Constitutional Court's annulment of the 5735 university-headscarf constitutional amendment lawful?

Unlawful79.2%
Lawful20.8%
24 Opinions
1 Questions
Final

Criminal procedure

Silivri Municipality/Bora Balcıoğlu custody and detention process

Were the June 12, 2026 custody, search, and seizure measures against Bora Balcıoğlu and other suspects in the Silivri Municipality investigation lawful?

Unlawful0.0%
Lawful0.0%
1 Opinions
3 Questions
Investigation

Family law

Indefinite poverty alimony and the Constitutional Court annulment

Was the Constitutional Court's annulment of the phrase allowing poverty alimony to be requested indefinitely lawful?

Unlawful60.0%
Lawful40.0%
23 Opinions
1 Questions
Short decision issued; reasoned judgment pending

Constitutional adjudication

5651 social-network-provider obligations and Law no. 7253

Were the social-network-provider obligations introduced by Law no. 7253 lawful?

Unlawful66.7%
Lawful33.3%
19 Opinions
1 Questions
Partly in force after constitutional review

Family law

Marriage-officer authority for mufti offices and Constitutional Court rejection

Was the Constitutional Court's refusal to annul marriage-officer authority for mufti offices lawful?

Unlawful91.8%
Lawful8.2%
34 Opinions
1 Questions
In force after constitutional review